When exploring the world of electronic drums, one of the most critical components influencing both playability and practicality is the type of material used for the drumming surfaces, primarily differentiating between mesh heads and rubber pads.
These surfaces are what drummers strike with sticks, and their material significantly impacts the feel, rebound, noise level, and overall responsiveness of the instrument, directly affecting a drummer’s technique and enjoyment, making the pad type a paramount consideration when evaluating electronic drum sets or edrums.
The fundamental choice between mesh heads and rubber pads often delineates different tiers of electronic drum kits, influencing everything from the price point and durability to how closely the electronic drum set can replicate the experience of playing acoustic drums.
Therefore, understanding the inherent differences between these two types of drum pads is essential for any drummer, whether a beginner or experienced drummer, seeking the best electronic drum set for their specific needs and environment, especially for considerations like home practice or playing in spaces where noise is a concern, such as an apartment.
This comprehensive article will delve into a detailed comparison of mesh heads vs. rubber pads, dissecting their respective pros and cons across various crucial factors.
We will examine how each material impacts the feel and rebound, analyze their distinct noise characteristics and implications for practice environments, evaluate their durability and maintenance requirements, compare their typical cost and relationship to different budget levels of electronic drum sets, and discuss their influence on sensitivity and dynamics.
Furthermore, we will explore key factors drummers should consider when choosing between the two pad types based on their experience level, playing goals, and physical space.
Understanding these nuances is vital because the pad type isn’t merely a matter of preference; it fundamentally shapes the playing experience, influences the development of proper technique, and determines the suitability of a given electronic drum set for a particular user and their living situation, guiding prospective buyers towards making an informed decision in their search for the best electronic drum set.
Mesh Heads: The Acoustic Drum Feel Alike
What are Mesh Heads?
Mesh heads constitute a type of electronic drum pad constructed from a woven mesh fabric stretched over a drum shell, strikingly similar in appearance to the heads found on acoustic drums.
This construction involves multiple layers of a durable, fine mesh material, typically synthetic, tautly secured to a hoop that fits onto a drum shell, much like an acoustic drum head.
Unlike solid rubber pads, the mesh material is designed to be permeable, allowing air to pass through the tiny gaps in the weave upon impact, which significantly contributes to their unique feel and reduced noise output.
A key feature is their capacity for tunable tension, meaning the tightness of the mesh can be adjusted using standard drum keys, enabling drummers to customize the rebound and responsiveness of the pad to better match their individual preferences or simulate the feel of different types of acoustic drums.
This mechanical adjustability is a significant departure from the fixed nature of most rubber pads.
Pros of Mesh Heads:
One of the most compelling advantages of mesh heads is their ability to provide a more realistic feel and rebound, closely emulating that of acoustic drums.
The woven texture and air displacement upon impact offer a stick response that feels remarkably natural under the stick, providing a bounce and articulation that solid surfaces struggle to replicate.
This acoustic feel is paramount for drummers transitioning from or regularly playing acoustic drums, as it helps maintain muscle memory and refine techniques like ghost notes and subtle dynamics.
Furthermore, mesh heads are significantly quieter acoustically than rubber pads when struck.
The mesh material absorbs and diffuses the energy of the stick impact far more effectively than dense rubber, resulting in a much lower practice volume, making them an ideal choice for drummers living in apartments, shared houses, or any environment where minimizing noise is essential.
The tunable tension feature of mesh heads represents another substantial benefit, offering a level of customization rarely found with rubber pads.
By adjusting the tension of the mesh, drummers can fine-tune the rebound to be tighter or looser, mimicking the feel of different snare drums, toms, or even different tunings on acoustic drums.
This adjustability allows for a highly personalized playing surface that can be adapted to various playing styles or practice requirements.
Mesh heads also generally exhibit better dynamic response and sensitivity.
The material’s nature allows for a wider range of velocities to be accurately captured and translated into varying sound levels by the sound module, enabling more expressive and nuanced playing.
This superior triggering accuracy is crucial for capturing subtle stick work and ghost notes effectively.
Lastly, the more forgiving surface of mesh heads can be easier on wrists and hands during extended playing sessions.
The impact shock is absorbed and distributed by the mesh, reducing the strain and fatigue that can sometimes occur when repeatedly striking the harder surface of rubber pads, promoting healthier and longer practice sessions.
Cons of Mesh Heads:
Despite their numerous advantages, mesh heads do come with certain drawbacks, primarily their generally higher expense.
Electronic drum sets equipped with mesh heads are almost invariably more expensive than those utilizing rubber pads, especially at the entry-level.
The manufacturing process and materials used for mesh heads contribute to a higher production cost, which is then reflected in the retail price of the electronic drum kit.
While highly durable, mesh heads can potentially be less durable than solid rubber under certain extreme conditions or if mistreated.
Although designed to withstand significant impact, the woven fibers can potentially be damaged by sharp objects or excessive, uneven tensioning, although this is not a common issue with normal use.
Solid rubber pads, being dense and non-woven, are often perceived as being impervious to most physical damage under typical playing conditions.
Additionally, some drummers might find that mesh heads may have a slightly “bouncier” feel than they prefer, particularly those accustomed to very low-tension acoustic drums or specific types of rubber pads.
While adjustable, achieving a feel that perfectly replicates a very loose acoustic drum head might be challenging, and the inherent elasticity of the mesh can result in a higher natural rebound for some players.
Rubber Pads: Durable and Affordable Options
What are Rubber Pads?
Rubber pads represent the more traditional type of playing surface found on electronic drums, characterized by their construction from solid rubber or a composite material.
These drum pads typically consist of a dense rubber layer molded into a circular or sometimes hexagonal shape, often mounted onto a plastic base containing the triggering sensor.
The rubber material itself is designed to absorb stick impact and provide a playing surface.
Unlike mesh heads, rubber pads are solid and impermeable, meaning they do not displace air or have the same kind of physical give as mesh when struck.
They are generally not tunable in terms of tension, offering a fixed rebound and feel determined by the density and thickness of the rubber used in their construction.
This simpler manufacturing process contributes to their prominence on budget and entry-level electronic drum sets.
Pros of Rubber Pads:
A major advantage of rubber pads is their more affordable nature, making electronic drum sets equipped with them significantly more accessible, especially for beginners or those on a limited budget.
The materials and manufacturing process for rubber pads are typically less expensive than those for mesh heads, allowing manufacturers to offer full electronic drum kits at lower price points.
This affordability has historically made edrums more attainable for a wider audience.
Furthermore, rubber pads are renowned for being highly durable and low maintenance.
Their solid construction makes them exceptionally resistant to wear and tear, capable of withstanding aggressive playing and repeated impacts without significant degradation.
They are generally less susceptible to damage from accidental bumps or scrapes compared to the woven surface of mesh.
Many rubber pad kits feature a compact design, particularly entry-level models, which can be beneficial for drummers with limited space.
The pads themselves are often slimmer and mounted on more minimalist racks, allowing the entire electronic drum set to occupy a smaller footprint and, in some cases, be more easily folded or stored away when not in use.
While offering a different feel than acoustic drums, rubber pads provide a consistent feel.
The rebound and response remain largely the same across the entire surface of the pad and over time, offering a predictable playing experience that can be advantageous for practicing rudiments and developing consistent stick control.
This consistency contrasts with mesh heads where tension changes can alter the feel.
Cons of Rubber Pads:
Conversely, rubber pads have several notable drawbacks when compared to mesh heads.
Their primary disadvantage is their louder acoustic noise when struck.
Although quieter than hitting a hard, non-dampened surface, the impact of the stick on dense rubber produces a distinct “thud” or “slap” sound that is significantly more audible in the room than the quiet whisper of mesh heads.
This makes practicing in noise-sensitive environments like apartments more challenging and potentially disruptive.
Rubber pads also offer a less realistic feel and rebound compared to acoustic drums.
The solid, dense surface provides a much different stick response, often described as harder or less natural than the bounce of an acoustic drum head or mesh head.
This can feel jarring for drummers accustomed to acoustic drums and may not translate as effectively to developing technique that transfers seamlessly to an acoustic kit.
The harder surface of rubber pads can feel harder on wrists and hands, potentially causing fatigue during extended playing sessions.
The impact shock is less absorbed than with mesh, transmitting more vibration back up the stick to the player’s hands and arms, which some drummers find uncomfortable over time.
Unlike mesh heads, rubber pads offer limited or no tension adjustment.
The rebound and feel are fixed by the pad’s design, removing the ability to customize the playing surface to personal preference or to simulate different drum tunings.
Finally, rubber pads may have less nuanced dynamic response and sensitivity compared to mesh.
Achieving a wide range of volumes and accurately triggering subtle ghost notes can be more challenging, as the pad material may not register very light hits as effectively or provide as smooth a transition between different velocity levels as a good mesh head.
Direct Comparison: Mesh vs. Rubber
A direct comparison between mesh heads and rubber pads highlights their fundamental differences and helps illuminate why one might be preferred over the other depending on a drummer’s priorities.
Evaluating key performance indicators side-by-side provides clarity.
Feel and Rebound:
Regarding feel and rebound, mesh heads are generally considered superior for acoustic feel.
The woven texture and adjustable tension allow them to replicate the bounce and stick response of acoustic drums much more closely than rubber pads.
Rubber pads, while offering a consistent rebound, provide a harder, less natural feel that some drummers liken to practicing on a solid block or a basic practice pad.
For drummers prioritizing a playing experience akin to acoustic drums, mesh heads offer a distinct advantage.
Noise Level:
The noise level difference is one of the most significant distinctions; mesh heads are significantly quieter.
The mesh material absorbs the impact of the stick, producing only a faint whisper or swish sound acoustically.
Rubber pads, conversely, create a noticeable “thud” or “slap” upon impact, which, while quieter than acoustic drums, can still be disruptive in quiet environments.
For practicing in apartments or late at night, mesh heads are the clear winner for minimizing ambient sound.
Durability:
Both materials boast impressive durability, but rubber is often considered slightly more robust against heavy impact.
The solid nature of rubber pads makes them extremely resilient to consistent, forceful hitting.
Mesh heads, while very durable in normal use, can theoretically be damaged by sharp objects or improper tensioning, though this is uncommon.
For sheer, brute force resistance over extended periods, rubber pads have a slight edge in perceived indestructibility.
Cost:
In terms of cost, rubber pads are typically more budget-friendly.
Electronic drum sets featuring primarily rubber pads are generally found in the entry-level price range, making them the most affordable option for those looking to start drumming.
Electronic drum kits with mesh heads are positioned in the mid-range to professional tiers and come with a higher price tag.
Sensitivity and Dynamics:
For sensitivity and dynamics, mesh heads often offer better response.
The design allows for more nuanced triggering, capturing a wider range of velocities from soft ghost notes to powerful accents more accurately.
This translates to a more expressive playing experience.
Rubber pads can be less sensitive to very light hits and may not provide as smooth a dynamic curve, sometimes resulting in a more “on or off” triggering feel depending on the quality of the pad and sound module.
Maintenance:
Regarding maintenance, both types are relatively low maintenance.
Rubber pads require little more than occasional cleaning.
Mesh heads are also low maintenance but have the added factor that the mesh heads themselves can be replaced if they wear out or get damaged, similar to replacing an acoustic drum head.
This adds a minor potential future cost but also extends the lifespan of the pad unit itself.
Here is a summary comparison table:
| Feature | Mesh Heads | Rubber Pads |
|---|---|---|
| Feel/Rebound | More realistic, closer to acoustic, tunable | Firmer, consistent, less like acoustic, fixed |
| Noise Level | Very quiet | Louder (distinct “thud”) |
| Durability | Very durable, heads replaceable | Extremely durable, low susceptibility to damage |
| Cost | Higher | Lower |
| Sensitivity | Generally better, wider dynamic range | Good, but sometimes less nuanced dynamics |
| Comfort | Easier on wrists/hands | Can cause fatigue for some players |
| Adjustability | Tunable tension | Generally fixed |
Which One is Right for You? (Factors to Consider)
Choosing between mesh heads and rubber pads ultimately depends on your individual circumstances, goals, and preferences as a drummer.
Several key factors should heavily influence your decision-making process.
Your Budget:
Your available budget is often the most significant determining factor when selecting an electronic drum set.
If you are working with a limited budget, entry-level kits predominantly featuring rubber pads will be the most accessible option, offering a functional drumming experience without a high initial cost.
If your budget allows for a larger investment, moving into the mid-range or high-end territory will unlock kits featuring mesh heads, providing a more premium feel and performance but at a higher price.
Your Playing Experience Level:
Your playing experience level can also guide your choice.
Beginners can certainly start and learn effectively on kits with rubber pads, as they provide a solid foundation for learning rhythm and coordination.
However, if a beginner intends to eventually transition to acoustic drums or wishes to develop technique that translates more directly to the acoustic kit from the outset, starting with mesh heads might be advantageous due to the more similar feel.
Experienced drummers, particularly those accustomed to the feel of acoustic drums, often strongly prefer mesh heads for their realism and tunable rebound.
Your Practice Environment:
Your practice environment is a crucial consideration, especially regarding noise.
If you live in an apartment, a shared living space, or have close neighbors, the quieter acoustic sound of mesh heads makes them the far superior choice for minimizing disturbance.
Rubber pads, being louder, are better suited for environments where noise is less of a concern, such as a detached house or a dedicated practice space.
Your Playing Style and Goals:
Consider your playing style and goals as a drummer.
If your primary goal is to practice silently, work on basic rhythms, or use the electronic drum set as a MIDI controller for recording, rubber pads can fulfill these needs adequately and affordably.
However, if you aim to replicate the experience of playing acoustic drums, develop nuanced technique that relies on realistic rebound and sensitivity, or perform expressively with a wide dynamic range, mesh heads are better equipped to support these objectives.
For drummers focused on genres requiring subtle dynamics or complex stick work, the enhanced sensitivity of mesh heads is a significant benefit.
Portability and Space:
Finally, think about portability and space.
While not a strict rule, some entry-level kits with rubber pads are designed to be more compact and easily foldable, making them a potentially better choice for drummers with very limited space or those who need to frequently set up and pack down their kit.
Electronic drum sets with mesh heads often feature pads that are closer to acoustic drum sizes and mounted on more substantial racks, taking up a larger footprint.
Here is a list of key factors to consider when choosing:
- Budget: How much are you willing to spend?
- Experience Level: Are you a beginner or an experienced player?
- Practice Location: Will you be playing in a noise-sensitive environment like an apartment?
- Playing Goals: Do you want to replicate the acoustic drumming experience or just need a quiet practice tool?
- Space Available: How much room do you have for the drum set?
Mesh Heads and Rubber Pads in “Best Electronic Drum Sets”
The type of pads included is a significant differentiator and often a defining characteristic when discussing the “Best Electronic Drum Sets” across various price points.
Generally speaking, as you move up the hierarchy of electronic drum kits, the prevalence of mesh heads increases, and they become a standard feature on mid-range to high-end models.
High-end and professional-grade electronic drum sets, often lauded as the “best” in terms of performance and realism, almost exclusively feature mesh heads on the snare and tom pads, and frequently for the kick drum pad as well.
Brands like Roland’s V-Drums (particularly their TD-17, TD-27, and TD-50 series) and higher-end Yamaha DTX kits are prime examples where the inclusion of multi-ply, tunable mesh heads is a key selling point, contributing significantly to their premium price and reputation for providing an acoustic feel and superior triggering.
These kits are often considered the “best” for experienced drummers, recording, and serious practice due to the playability offered by the mesh heads.
In the mid-range, the landscape becomes more varied.
Many manufacturers offer excellent electronic drum sets in this category that strike a balance, often featuring a mesh head snare (the most played pad, where feel is arguably most critical) and rubber pads for the toms and kick, or sometimes mesh heads for the snare and kick and rubber pads for the toms.
This hybrid approach allows manufacturers to offer some of the key benefits of mesh heads, particularly the realistic snare feel and quieter kick, while keeping the overall cost of the kit more accessible than an all-mesh high-end set.
These hybrid kits can represent a “best” value proposition for drummers seeking a significant upgrade from entry-level but who might not need or cannot afford a top-tier all-mesh kit.
Entry-level electronic drum sets, designed with affordability and accessibility in mind, predominantly feature rubber pads for all the drums.
While these kits may not offer the realistic feel or low noise of mesh heads, they provide a functional and durable platform for beginners to learn the fundamentals of drumming.
Brands like Alesis (many of their lower-priced Surge, Command, or Nitro kits), Carlsbro, and some Yamaha DTX models fall into this category.
For a beginner on a strict budget, an entry-level electronic drum set with rubber pads might represent the “best” option available to them, providing a stepping stone into the world of electronic drums.
It demonstrates that “best” is relative and depends on the user’s needs and constraints, not solely on having the most premium features like mesh heads.
Thus, while mesh heads are strongly associated with the best electronic drum sets in terms of realistic feel and performance, good quality rubber pads still have their place, particularly in the entry-level and some mid-range kits, offering durability and affordability that make edrums accessible to a wider audience.
The “best” kit incorporates the pad type that best aligns with the drummer’s individual requirements.
Conclusion: Making Your Choice
In conclusion, the debate between mesh heads vs. rubber pads on electronic drums is not about definitively declaring one universally better than the other; rather, it’s about understanding their distinct characteristics and determining which type best suits your specific needs as a drummer.
Mesh heads excel in providing a more realistic feel and rebound, closely mimicking acoustic drums, are significantly quieter acoustically, offer tunable tension for customization, and are generally easier on wrists during extended play.
These benefits make them highly desirable for experienced drummers, those prioritizing realistic technique transfer, and anyone needing to practice in noise-sensitive environments like apartments.
Conversely, rubber pads offer significant advantages in terms of cost and durability.
They are much more affordable, making electronic drum sets accessible to beginners and those on tighter budgets.
Their solid construction renders them exceptionally durable and low maintenance.
While they are acoustically louder than mesh and offer a less realistic feel, they provide a consistent playing surface that is perfectly adequate for learning fundamental rhythms and practicing silently with headphones in environments where the ambient pad noise is not a major concern.
The decision ultimately hinges on balancing various factors: your budget, your playing experience level, the acoustics of your practice environment, your drumming goals, and the available space.
If replicating the acoustic feel and minimizing noise are top priorities and your budget allows, investing in an electronic drum set with mesh heads is likely the best choice.
If affordability, robustness, and a consistent, no-frills practice surface are more important, and ambient pad noise is manageable, a kit with rubber pads can be an excellent and practical option.
Many mid-range kits offer a compromise, combining mesh heads on key pads like the snare with rubber pads elsewhere.
Ultimately, the best electronic drum set for you is one that fits your budget, aligns with your playing aspirations, and is suitable for your living situation.
We encourage prospective buyers to research specific models within their price range and, if possible, try playing on both mesh heads and rubber pads at a music store to personally experience the difference in feel and rebound before making their final decision.
Understanding these core differences empowers drummers to choose an instrument that will facilitate enjoyable and effective practice for years to come.
